Selkirk OMNI vs Speedup Tide 14H
Comparisons cover the paddles I've reviewed, so every score is mine. Pick any other paddle to request its review.

- More Spin
- More Forgiving
OMNI
$300 MSRP · Widebody · 16mm

- Tougher Grit
- Costs Less
Tide 14H
$153 w/ code · Hybrid · 14mm
No winner on this page on purpose. The numbers are below and the call is yours. Buying through my links or with code supports the testing at no extra cost to you. How this site makes money
OMNI
- Spins more: +41 RPM
- More forgiving: +1.6 twist weight
Tide 14H
- Grit tested more durable: +1.2
- Costs $147 less
By the numbers.
Scores run 0 to 10. Measurement bars are relative to each other.
OMNI
Tide 14H
Spin
RPM, lab average
2,305RPM
lab avg · 2 sourcesTop quarter
2,264RPM
lab avg · 2 sources
Power
drives and serves
8.0/10
8.2/10
Pop
speed off the face on short swings
8.5/10
8.5/10
Control
stability and a calm face
8.5/10
8.1/10
Spin score
how well it shapes the ball
8.0/10
8.8/10
Swing weight
lower swings quicker
112.0
brand claims
112.0
brand claims
Twist weight
higher forgives mishits
7.90
brand claimsTop 10% of the database
6.30
brand claims
Static weight
ounces on the scale
8.1oz
brand claims
8.0oz
brand claims
Grit durability
John Kew's wear test, Tier 1 lasts longest
Tier 3
Tier 4
Power, Pop, Control and Spin score are my scores on my 10-point scale. Every paddle starts from a default I compute from where its measurements land against the whole database, and I set the number myself once I've played the paddle. Power is drives and serves, Pop is speed off the face on short swings, Control is stability with a calm face, Spin score is how well it shapes the ball. Grit durability is John Kew's wear-test tier, Tier 1 the longest-lasting. Spin, swing weight, twist weight and static weight are raw measurements: “lab avg” averages the independent reviewer labs in my database (John Kew, Pickleball Studio, Matt's Pickleball, The Pickleball Blast), and “brand claims” is the manufacturer's published number. I don't own a bench rig, and I say so.
The build
| OMNI | Tide 14H | |
|---|---|---|
| Shape | Widebody | Hybrid |
| Core | 16mm, PureFoam (100% foam) | 14mm, PureFeel Core - MPP with TPE outer ring |
| Face | Multistrata proprietary layered face with InfiniGrit surface | FlexGrid Face - 3 layers Toray T700 carbon fiber (±45° layup) |
| Length × width | 15.95 × 8 in | 16.4 × 7.5 in |
| Handle | 5.6 in | 5.5 in |
| Certification | USAP (stated tournament-legal / USAP-compliant) | USAP approved (PBCoR .43) |
| MSRP | $300 | $169.99 |
| With code NICOTHELEFTY | – | $153 |
| Nico's score | 8.0 / 10 | 8.4 / 10 |
Still deciding?
I'll email you when either paddle drops $5 or more, and again at each new low. Stop anytime.